| Results by Date |
| Rk |
Date |
Mr |
Nr |
Comp |
Round |
V |
Crowd |
Scorers |
| 1 |
1881-10-01 Sat |
 |
 |
EFA Cup |
2nd |
First Tynecastle |
4500 |
Bob Waugh ;John Sweeney |
| [Frank Rourke] ;[Gillie Byrne 43] ;[James Flynn 46] ;[Thomas Lee] |
| 2 |
1894-05-31 Thu |
 |
 |
Rosebery Charity Cup |
Final |
Easter Road |
7500 |
Murphy og ;Willie Michael |
| [Allan Martin] ;[Allan Martin] ;[William [1] Smith] ;[Allan Martin] |
| 3 |
1922-04-26 Wed |
 |
 |
Wilson Cup |
SF |
Tynecastle Park |
8000 |
John Murphy 2 ;John Murphy |
| [Hugh Shaw] ;[Harry Ritchie pen] ;[Jimmy Buchanan] ;[Harry Ritchie] |
| 4 |
1935-04-23 Tue |
 |
 |
EoSS |
Final |
Easter Road |
4000 |
Urquhart og ;Tommy Walker pen |
| [Davy Anderson] ;[Davy Anderson 15] ;[Willie Black] ;[Davy Anderson] |
| 5 |
1939-09-23 Sat |
 |
 |
Friendly |
|
Tynecastle Park |
6000 |
Black Andrew ;Boyd Robert |
| [Bobby Nuttley] ;[Sammy Kean] ;[Bobby Nuttley] ;[Arthur H Milne] |
| 6 |
1941-09-06 Sat |
 |
 |
Wartime S |
|
Easter Road |
20000 |
Tommy Walker 40 ;Smith George B 55 |
| [W Finnigan 1] ;[J Combe 14] ;[G Smith 17] ;[R Baxter 31] |
| 7 |
1953-05-07 Thu |
 |
 |
EoSS |
Final |
Easter Road |
20000 |
Jimmy Wardhaugh 41 ;Jimmy Wardhaugh |
| [L Reilly 6] ;[L Reilly 7] ;[G Smith 40] ;[E Turnbull pen] |
| 8 |
1957-10-07 Mon |
 |
 |
Friendly |
|
Tynecastle Park |
25000 |
Willie Bauld 18 ;Jimmy Wardhaugh 25 |
| [T Preston 28] ;[T Preston 65] ;[J Baker 68] ;[T Preston 72] |
| 9 |
1961-03-29 Wed |
 |
 |
EoSS |
Final |
Easter Road |
6000 |
Willie Bauld ;Ian Crawford |
| [J Baxter 20] ;[J Baker 23] ;[E Stevenson] ;[J Baker 60] |